Compare
An honest comparison, including where we lose.
There are good home care platforms. Several do more than we do, and every one of them comes with support and updates, which this does not. This page sets out how they charge, what each covers, and when one of them is the better choice.
02Two ways to pay
A subscription charges every month. This is paid once.
Established platforms mostly price by active client, usually with a monthly minimum, an onboarding fee and a yearly increase. A few price by user. None of the eighteen alternatives we studied sells a licence you keep.
- The meter
- Own it (Hearthway)None. Any number of clients, caregivers, office users and family members.
- Rent it (a subscription)Active clients, users or visits, counted every month.
- Support and updates
- Own it (Hearthway)None, ever. Your own developer or IT provider looks after your copy.
- Rent it (a subscription)Included in the fee. Someone answers when it breaks.
- Getting started
- Own it (Hearthway)Install it yourself from the guide, or buy the one-time install for $1,490. You load your own data.
- Rent it (a subscription)Often a setup fee due at signing, with onboarding and data conversion done for you.
- Year four and five
- Own it (Hearthway)Your AWS bill and your own upkeep. Nothing to us.
- Rent it (a subscription)The monthly fee, usually a little higher each year.
- Leaving
- Own it (Hearthway)Switch it off. The software, the source code and your data stay where they are.
- Rent it (a subscription)Export what the vendor lets you export, within its notice period.
03Capability by capability
Where we match, where we are behind, and where we will not go.
Our own column is marked hard: if it is not built, it is a no. The established-platform column is marked generously wherever public evidence is thin. The first row is the one where every subscription is ahead of us, and it matters most.
| Capability | Hearthwaytoday | Hearthwayat general availability | Established platformtypical subscription | DIY stacksheets and apps |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vendor support and updatesNone from us, ever. With a subscription they come with the fee. With a DIY stack each tool has its own vendor, but nobody supports the way you joined them. | No | No | Yes | Partly |
| Scheduling and open-shift coverage | Yes | Yes | Yes | Partly |
| Caregiver app and GPS visit verificationOurs installs from the browser; handset and offline proof are conditions of general availability. | Partly | Yes | Yes | Partly |
| Phone or landline visit verificationOffice-recorded punches today; the automated line is connected at installation. | Partly | Yes | Yes | No |
| Clients and care plansVersioned plans and tasks; no assessment scoring. | Partly | Partly | Yes | Partly |
| Client and family portal | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Messaging and notificationsIn-app today; email and push are connected at installation. | Partly | Yes | Yes | Partly |
| Private-pay billing, invoices, statements | Yes | Yes | Yes | Partly |
| Payroll export or integrationA review sheet and CSV; no payroll-provider connection. | Partly | Partly | Yes | Partly |
| Accounting (QuickBooks)QuickBooks Desktop file; QuickBooks Online is not in this version. | Partly | Partly | Yes | Yes |
| VA Community Care (referrals, authorizations, claims)Prepares claims; you submit. Established platforms range from partial to full. | Partly | Partly | Partly | No |
| Medicaid state EVV aggregatorDIY agencies use the free state system for Medicaid visits. | No | No | Yes | Yes |
| Electronic claims (837 out, 835 in)Not in this version. | No | No | Yes | Partly |
| Reporting and analyticsFixed dashboards; no report builder. | Partly | Partly | Yes | No |
| Recruiting, HR and training | No | No | Partly | No |
| Data ownership and portabilityYour own AWS account and the source code; proven once the installer has run on a clean account. | Partly | Yes | Partly | Yes |
| Multiple locations or franchise controls | No | No | Yes | No |
● covered · ◐ partly covered, an add-on, or not established by published evidence · ○ not offered.
“Today” is the product as it stands. “At general availability” adds only what is already built but not yet connected or proven in a live agency: the phone line, push and email, and the caregiver app tested on handsets. Nothing new is assumed, and nothing is added to a copy after it is sold.
The established-platform column is desk research from vendor pages and directory listings, as of 2026-11-11. It describes a typical established per-client platform, not any one vendor. Check each claim with the vendor you are considering.
04Prices we can show by name
Only the figures the vendors publish themselves.
Most home care platforms quote on request, and we will not put our guess of someone’s price beside their name. These are the ones that publish or list a price.
| Vendor | How it charges | Published or listed figures |
|---|---|---|
| ShiftCareSource for ShiftCare | Per user (caregivers + admins) / month, min 5 users | $13 per user a month (caregivers and office) (published) · $65 monthly minimum (published) · no setup fee (published) |
| AnkotaSource for Ankota | Per active client / month with a monthly minimum | $11 per active client a month (vendor listing) · $59 monthly minimum (vendor listing) |
| Generations Homecare SystemSource for Generations Homecare System | Per staff user / month, 5-user minimum, from ~$330/mo | $9 per user a month (caregivers and office) (vendor listing) · $330 monthly minimum (vendor listing) |
| Aaniie (formerly Smartcare)Source for Aaniie (formerly Smartcare) | Flat to 15 clients, then per client / month; all-inclusive | $13 per active client a month (published) · $195 monthly minimum (published) |
| AveeCareSource for AveeCare | Per peak active client / month, no minimum, no contract | $6 per active client a month (published) · no monthly minimum (published) · no setup fee (published) |
| CarecentaSource for Carecenta | Free to 5 clients; flat $99/mo to 100 clients (5 users) + $799 setup; enterprise custom | $99 a month, flat (vendor listing) · $799 setup (vendor listing) |
As of 2026-11-11, from each vendor’s own pricing page or directory listing. Prices and plans change, and a directory figure is often a “starting at” number. Follow the source link and ask for a written quote. Names are used only to identify the products.
05Choose a subscription instead
When renting is the right call.
- No one on your team or on call can look after software. This is the one that decides it for most agencies. A subscription comes with someone to call.
- You want support, updates, training or the option of a refund.
- You bill Medicaid and need your state’s EVV aggregator connected.
- You run several locations or a franchise and need roll-up reporting.
- You need claims filed electronically, QuickBooks Online or card payments.
- You want recruiting, onboarding paperwork and training in the same product.
- You need a vendor with customer references, a vendor BAA or a security attestation.
- You are at about 40 clients or more, price is the only question, and a flat low-cost plan covers what you need. On price alone it will beat us.
06Choose to own
When owning is the right call.
- You have technical help: a technical owner, an in-house IT person, or a developer or IT provider on call.
- You are a single-location, private-pay agency, with or without VA work.
- You are tired of a bill that follows your client count and rises at renewal.
- You have many caregivers for each client, and a per-user plan would charge you for every one.
- You want the software and your records in an account in your agency’s name, with the source code in your hands.
- You want to change the software to suit your agency, with your own developer.
- This version does the job as it stands. You are not buying for anything that might come later.
07Against spreadsheets and separate apps
The cheapest software is paid for in office hours.
A calendar, a spreadsheet, a clock-in app and QuickBooks cost very little in cash. For most small agencies they cost less than our licence over three years, before anyone counts the office time.
What the paper leaves out is the retyping. Each visit goes from the calendar to the invoice to the payroll sheet by hand, and each copy is a chance for the hours to disagree. The case for owning is one record from the schedule to the pay sheet, a page for the family, and VA authorizations that count themselves.
If that is worth less to you than three office hours a week, keep the spreadsheet. It is a reasonable choice for a small agency, and it needs nobody to maintain it.
08Whoever you choose
Six questions to ask any vendor, us included.
- 1
What will I have paid after five years? Ask for the number with setup fees and the yearly increase applied, in writing.
- 2
What happens to the price when I grow? When you pass the next client tier, add office users, or hire ten more caregivers.
- 3
What costs extra? Texting, phone verification, training, a family portal, VA billing help.
- 4
How do I get my data out, and what does it cost? In what format, how soon, and for how long after you leave.
- 5
What is not in it? Ours is on one page, under “Not in this version”, “Not offered” and “Never included”.
- 6
Who do I call when it breaks? With a subscription, the vendor. With us, your own developer or IT provider. Know the name of that person before you buy.
Hear when it goes on sale.
One email, when it opens. From then the licence is $10,000, or $7,500 for the first 20 agencies or 90 days after general availability, whichever comes first.
Not on sale until general availability. The launch list costs nothing and commits you to nothing.