Visit verification
Do private-pay home care agencies need EVV?
Electronic visit verification is required for Medicaid-funded care, not private pay. What the rule covers, why private-pay agencies verify visits anyway, and what to check.
If every client pays you directly, no federal rule makes you verify a single visit electronically. Most well-run private-pay agencies do it anyway.
In short
- No. The federal EVV mandate covers Medicaid-funded personal care and home health services. An agency whose clients all pay privately is not covered by it. The reasons to verify visits anyway are practical: settling billing questions, reassuring families, paying caregivers accurately and being ready for payers that are starting to ask.
- The rule names six things a system must capture for each visit.
- If you bill any Medicaid at all, your state decides which system you must use, and some states allow only one.
- Verifying visits and being connected to a state EVV system are different things. We do the first and not the second.
What does the EVV rule actually require?
It requires states to verify Medicaid-funded visits electronically. Section 12006 of the 21st Century Cures Act set the deadlines: personal care services by January 1, 2020, and home health services by January 1, 2023. It applies to care paid for by Medicaid. It says nothing about care a family pays for themselves.
The rule lists six things to be recorded for each visit:
- The type of service
- Who received it
- The date
- The location
- Who provided it
- The time it began and ended
Each state then chose how to do this. Some run an open model and let agencies pick from approved vendors. Others require every agency to use one system. Reviews from agencies in closed states say as much: they use the state’s vendor because the state allows nothing else.
So does a private-pay agency need EVV?
Not by federal law. If none of your visits is billed to Medicaid, the mandate does not reach you, and nobody is waiting for your visit data.
Two cautions. State licensing rules for home care agencies vary, and a few say something about how visits are recorded, so read your own state’s rules. And the moment you take a single Medicaid client, that client’s visits fall under your state’s EVV programme, even if the rest of your agency is private pay.
Why do private-pay agencies verify visits anyway?
Because a visit you can prove is a visit you can bill, pay and defend. There are four everyday reasons.
Billing questions
A daughter calls to say her father’s caregiver left early on Tuesday. With a recorded clock-in and clock-out, that is a two-minute conversation. Without one, it is your caregiver’s memory against hers.
Families
Families of private-pay clients are paying their own money, often from a distance. Knowing that the caregiver arrived, and when, is much of what they are buying.
Payroll
Paper timesheets round. Phones do not. When the time on the pay sheet is the time that was recorded, fewer paychecks are disputed.
Other payers are starting to ask
The home care trade association reported in April 2026 that the VA’s next round of community care contracts calls for electronic visit verification. The details were not settled when we wrote this. If VA work is in your plans, verified visits are worth having in place before somebody requires them.
What should a private-pay agency look for?
Look for verification that survives the way care really happens. Caregiver reviews of home care apps repeat the same complaints: the app will not let them clock in, the GPS puts them in the wrong place, the clock-out button disappears. A few things prevent most of it.
- A boundary you can adjust. Homes on large lots and apartment buildings need different settings.
- A verdict, not a lock. “Away from the home” should ask the office to look. It should not stop a caregiver clocking in at the pharmacy on an errand.
- A way to work without signal. Basements and rural roads are where the app is needed most.
- A fallback for caregivers without smartphones. A phone call from the client’s landline is still verification.
- The accuracy shown. “At the home, plus or minus 19 metres” is honest. A green tick is not.
What people get wrong about EVV
They treat “has GPS clock-in” and “does EVV” as the same claim. They are not. Verifying a visit means recording the six things above. Being an EVV system for Medicaid means sending them to the state’s aggregator in the state’s format, and being accepted by the state to do so.
Hearthway is on the first side of that line only. It records the time and the place of each clock-in and clock-out, gives a plain verdict with the accuracy shown, and has a phone route for caregivers without a smartphone. It is not connected to any state system and has not been approved for any state programme. If Medicaid is most of your revenue, we are the wrong choice, and we would rather say so here.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is EVV required for private pay home care? No. The federal mandate in the 21st Century Cures Act applies to Medicaid-funded personal care and home health services. Care paid for privately is outside it. Check your state’s home care licensing rules as well, since those are set state by state.
What are the six EVV data elements? The type of service, the person who received it, the date, the location, the person who provided it, and the time the service began and ended.
Do I need EVV if I have one Medicaid client? Yes, for that client’s Medicaid-funded visits. Your state’s EVV programme applies to them, whatever the rest of your payer mix. Some states offer a free system for exactly this situation.
Does the VA require EVV for home care? Not across the board today. Industry reporting in 2026 says the VA’s next community care contracts call for it, without final details at the time of writing. Ask your network administrator for its current requirements.
See how the verdict looks on a real visit
The caregiver section of our product page shows a real clock-in with its verdict, and the office section shows the same visit from the other side of the desk. If you are weighing subscriptions, our pricing guide lists the questions to ask each vendor.
Written by the Hearthway team. This is general information, not legal advice; your state’s rules are the ones that apply to you. About us.